BigWind gets beat Big in Ohio and Indiana

There is hope. As the truth about industrial wind turbines spreads, the people speak…through their votes. Do NOT get complacent, however, as BigWind has lobbyists who constantly approach our legislators.
We reported, yesterday that Van Wert County, Ohio, had a big win as their anti-wind Commissioner candidate beat a candidate who is a lease holder and was taking money for her campaign for the wind company. The numbers 72% to 28% win for their anti-wind candidate who was an incumbent. In our neighboring state, the good news was contagious….
ELECTION RESULTS: The “vocal minority” is the MAJORITY! Anti-wind groups win big in SIX Indiana counties fighting wind:
It was a very good night for almost all of our counties fighting wind. Huge victories in Fulton, Cass, Miami, Henry, Montgomery and Warren Counties last night as Pro-Property Rights Anti-Wind candidates swept the polls and sent a strong message to the powers-that-be that we are not backing down and will stand up for our rights! We are sad to report that our friends in Tipton County had a tough night but will continue the fight to keep new wind energy projects out of their county.
Key candidate wins for rural property rights include:
Henry County – biggest winner of the night! They won three seats on the County Council and a County Commissioner seat! They fought hard for the win and came out on top all across the board! Way to go, Henry County! It was truly a group effort. So proud to fight in Indiana with these fine people!

Fulton County – Fulton County needs to turn over the Area Plan Commission Board, and now has a good start. Two pro-wind officials on the Plan Commission – the surveyor and an appointed County Council member chose not to run again, (We believe because they thought they would lose based on pro-wind statements they have made to the anti-wind crowd that were not received well in the past).
The most contested race in Fulton County was Fulton County Surveyor, and we won! Also, on Fulton County Council – two were seats won by anti-wind candidates. One was a recently discovered anti-wind incumbant whose stance on wind energy we did not know until we sent out a pledge letter asking for candidates to promise to keep Fulton County wind-turbine free.
Miami County – Commissioner and detested RES Wind Land Lease Agent Josh Francis was running for County Council and was destroyed by his competition!
Cass County – a huge upset as one of the pro-wind Commissioner “Kings of Cass County” was dethroned with an anti-wind candidate! Also we were able to win a seat on the Cass County Council, and have an uncontested candidate who will also be running for County Council in the fall! Here’s an article about their win:
Warren County – voted out (as in “You’re fired!”) a pro-wind commissioner who is said to have originally brought big wind into the county and they replaced him with a pro-property rights candidate! Way to go!
Montgomery County was able to hang on to two current anti-wind County Council members, and pro-wind was running against them, so hats off to them on their wins.
Pulaski County had a win as their believed-to-be on our side Commissioner handily won his primary and can perhaps be more free now to be more aggressive in getting wind kicked out of Pulaski County for good.

Apex Clean Energy handed big ‘blow’ in Van Wert, Ohio


Screen Shot 2018-05-09 at 7.19.32 AM

The Van Wert county overwhelmingly said NO to a county commissioner who strongly supported  Apex Clean Energy!  The same occurred, across the border, in Cass County, IN…

The TRUTH is hard to hide and it is out. BigWind is a bully across America. It divides families and communities and damages our energy security b/c it is an intermittent energy source that must be backed up 100% of the time. People are becoming educated….

Do you think our legislators are paying attention???? Columbus should be, particularly before they sign a new law that shortens our setbacks!!!

Time to cut through the BigWind bull in Ohio…

Reading below, you would ‘think’ that the Mercer county engineer did something odd, by notifying county residents that BigWind was, again, prowling in the area. The reality? Apex, which apparently now wants to be called, ACE, SCHEDULED A MEETING WITH THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, MID MONTH…ACE has, since this, CANCELLED their meeting.  Their failure to build in S Van Wert county has NOTHING to do with setbacks- that’s a political ponzi scheme- instead, ACE can’t get to a substation because educated land owners refuse to give them the rights. They are having to ‘renew’ leases because this reality has stalled their plans….plans to desecrate the landscape, plans to destroy bird/bat habitat, plans to harm the health of some neighbors.  There is no doubt that ACE WANTS to acquire more land- ALL of the BigWind companies do!….
Mercer County Engineer Jim Wiechart claims Apex Clean Energy has been attempting to secure land rights from property owners in northern Mercer County for wind turbines, without notifying the public or local governments.
Company representatives, though, told the newspaper they’re not actively seeking any new properties in northern Mercer County at this time.
“Because your livelihood and the well-being of your land is important, I would like you to be aware of this proposed large scale industrial wind turbine project that Apex Clean Energy is attempting to develop and how you, as landowners, can help protect your land,” Wiechart wrote in a news released he issued on Friday afternoon.
Local officials, Wiechart said, have limited to no authority when it comes to regulating “large landscape-altering projects.”
“Instead, this authority currently resides with the Ohio Power Siting Board,” Wiechart wrote. “The only real and tangible method to preclude a landscape altering development across a multiple township area is for the company (Apex Clean Energy) to be unable to acquire land rights in a geographic foot print to site.”
Weichart requested that all landowners approached by ACE, or any other wind development company, educate themselves about the “significant rights” they are granting before signing any contracts…
“We’re renewing leases, but we’re not really aggressively pursuing anything,” Moser said. “Right now nothing’s happening because of the setbacks at the state level, so there’s not going to be anything happening in Van Wert or Mercer County until the legislation figures things out at the state level.”…
“Currently Apex has invested over $19 million in Ohio, so it’s hard to keep investing when you can’t build,” Moser said. “We don’t really want to put a lot more money out there until we know what’s going to happen with (the legislation), so we’re just kind of on hold. I think there’s just people trying to stir the pot in Mercer County, to be honest.”…
Steve Caminati, senior manager of strategic engagement at ACE, also said the company was not looking to acquire any new properties in northern Mercer County at this time. He wondered aloud if there might be confusion concerning old land leases, but did not elaborate further, saying he needs to look into the matter.
“With the current state setback requirements, this project is pretty much on hold,” Caminati said.

Source: Official claims wind company seeking land for turbines | The Daily Standard Stories

Ohio Senator wants BigWind to spread across the state

As we enter another year, we see that, as the proliferation of industrial wind continues, more people and communities are being harmed by the adverse impacts. We know THE issue for us in 2017 will be efforts to reduce setbacks.

Meanwhile, we can count on Ohio Senator Cliff Hite to lead that assault on our property. Remarkably, in an interview with the Findlay/Hancock County newspaper, Hite says, ““I’m the little guy in this fight.” The article goes on to say “Hite’s 1st Senate District includes wind turbine-rich Van Wert and Paulding counties, and Hardin County, which has multiple turbine projects in the making. But policies promoting renewable energy, like wind and solar, would be job creators for the entire state, Hite said. Amazon, Google and Microsoft have told lawmakers and the governor they would like to locate in Ohio. (Remember, however, that Ohio is WEAK for wind and the turbine here only produce appox 40% of the energy they could theoretically produce-if spinning all the time)But they first want the state to adopt a consistent policy involving renewable energy sources. Besides the potential economic benefits, Hite favors wind and solar energy for their environmental benefits. “I believe with all my heart as a Republican that it is our job to make this state better, when it comes to the air,” he said. “This shouldn’t be just a Democrat issue. This shouldn’t be just a few factions out there … We should be united to do what we can.”

So it seems that Cliff Hite feels his district needs to sacrifice everything so that THEORETICAL jobs can be created someplace else in the state and everyone in Ashtabula can breathe clean air. Does Hite think his constituents are dumb enough to believe that? We hope many readers will resolve in 2017 to write lots of letters to your local papers. We observe that the Ohio press is continuing to cover the perspectives of the environmental community and not the other side of the issue. With that in mind, we feature several important stories today….

Highlights of other wind projects outside of Ohio include:

PENNSYLVANIA: In Carbon County, citizens are at a boiling point over a project by Atlantic Wind, a subsidiary of Avangrid Renewables (formerly known as Iberdrola) Avangrid has received anonymous notes from area residents including “…We have ex-military and many avid hunters in our area who will have their lives and property affected if this project goes through. I for one will not forget who is attempting to do this to my family and my neighbors. Take care for now. A concerned citizen from Jim Thorpe, PA. PUT THEM WHERE THEY ARE NOT SO NEAR TO DEVELOPMENTS!!!” “Then on Sept. 15, a Facebook post referenced the 2013 Ross Township mass shooting, which left three people dead and several others wounded during a supervisors meeting. Rockne Newell, the shooter, had feuded with the township for years about his property. One commenter, according to Atlantic Wind’s court filing, said, “Well, when you push someone till they have nowhere to go and then take what they own … well … not defending him but look what they did to him over a period of time,” according to the posting included with Atlantic Wind’s court complaint.

NORTH CAROLINA: In reference to an Amazon project being developed by Avangrid (fka Iberdrola) – “Generally speaking, property owners’ concerns with wind farms is that turbines will be built too close to their residences. They warn the turbines’ low but steady noise, as well as “shadow flicker” from spinning blades, will be a constant irritant. Those factors, and the constant sight of turbines, makes property owners worry they won’t be able to profitably sell their land one day.” A second project in the area being developed by Apex is now facing similar local opposition. “In the Winslow case, an Apex tower is less than 900 feet from their property line and the area is subject to up to 660 hours per year of shadow flicker, according to the petition. Apex IS the company hoping to build, soon in Van Wert county! Flicker is the term used to describe a strobe-light effect during certain times of the year as the turbine blades pass between the sun and a person or object on the ground.” In November, the Perquimans Board of Commissioners blocked the project on the Perquimans side, voting 3-2 to deny Apex a conditional use permit it needs and now Apex has taken the County Commissioners to Court.

WISCONSIN: Manitowoc County will join St. Croix, Brown and Kewaunee counties in requesting the State of Wisconsin fund a study on the Low Frequency Noise impact of wind turbines on human health. “We need some guidance in getting some parameters set for where this low-frequency noise situation is,” Hoffman said. ”It is going to be a small area of Manitowoc County that these wind towers are going into, and I consider this heavily populated. … I think we need to come up with something that is solid and concrete, and we don’t have the ability at the county level to have somebody that can go up there and say ‘This is where those wind mills should be.’”

MICHIGAN: A remorseful leaseholder writes a letter to the Editor saying “We gave up our beautiful community, we are giving up our health, our electric bills have risen and there doesn’t seem to be anyway out except leaving.” “They are now planning on moving, but have been told by Realtors that they will have trouble selling their home because of the turbines.” “I now believe that the only safe place for turbines is at least a mile and a half from anyone’s home.”

IOWA: Kossuth County is considering revisions to its local wind ordinance to address Shadow Flicker and to limit the number of turbines that can be built in the County. Eric Briones, project developer for Amshore US Wind LLC, said via email that in its current form the county ordinance is certainly one of the most restrictive versions proposed in the state of Iowa. “It limits both business opportunity and the rights of landowners, and jeopardizes what could be hundreds of millions of dollars in economic impact to the county and schools with potential projects,” Briones said. “Limiting the amount of turbines that can be constructed in the county completely strips away the rights of the citizens of Kossuth County who may want to develop their land for economic gain. “Debora Blume, Director of Communications for MidAmerican Energy Company, said in an email that through the county’s process, MidAmerican continues to provide information and its views with respect to the proposed 1,600-foot setback from occupied residences. “While we have successfully built and operated wind projects in 23 Iowa counties over the past 12 years, we have not built a wind project in a county with an occupied residence setback requirement that’s greater than 1,250 feet,” she said. “MidAmerican will evaluate our planned development after the setback and other wind ordinance requirements are established by Kossuth County, and then determine any next steps.”

Probably the most troubling statement from these articles is that someone with a turbine 900 feet from their property line could experience 660 hours of shadow flicker. The current Ohio maximum is 30 hours per year at a residence measured by considering the light coming through a theoretical window imagined by computer modeling. If the North Carolina experience is accurate, the shadow flicker intrusion on a neighboring property would exceed the “indoor standard” by 22 times! This is an area where we need to get a better idea of the current setback impacts as well as future impacts if setbacks are at risk of being shortened.

Hopefully our efforts in the coming year will be helped by swift action from the Trump Administration. The Washington Times editorializes about what Trump should do when he takes office, including doing away with the Department of Energy.. “ In the meantime, we’ve endured wasteful, panicked policies such as massive subsidies for the wind and solar power, and electric cars. Worst of all, Congress has saddled consumers with ethanol subsidies and mandates. These boondoggles cost us billions of dollars, and none of them are commercially viable in their own right. In fact, the DOE has produced no dramatic breakthroughs in energy technology despite 40 years of trying (and failing) to pick winners.”

pic from

Stay vigilant: Proof that BigWind spreads like an algae bloom

Screen Shot 2016-08-05 at 8.58.46 AM

We are thankful that Allen County, Ohio, said NO to Apex Clean Energy and denied the use of the RR to build an energy transmission line. One argument was that industrial wind sites spread like an algae bloom.  In other words, the boundaries of the initial site expand over time, in multiple phases. What may ‘appear’ to be one site becomes multiple sites over a short period of time. If Apex is successful in building the LongPrairie Wind site in Southern Van Wert county, all neighboring counties are at risk….

As many may now know, the Towns of Yates and Somerset, The County Legislatures of Orleans, Niagara and Erie, The Western New York Delegation of State Legislators along with many other public and private organizations have opposed the proposed siting of the Lighthouse Wind Project in Somerset and Yates. Additionally, APEX has now proposed yet another industrial wind turbine project…
Interesting new information has come to light however. The original proposed site of APEX’s Lighthouse Wind Industrial Wind Turbine project has expanded from the original siting plan

To a significantly modified project…

This represents a significant southward expansion of the project.
In other news, I have heard that there are APEX signs now posted in the town of Ridgeway. As concerned citizens, we must ask:
Has APEX now also targeted Ridgeway for Industrial Wind Turbines?
Is APEX trying to “connect the dots” between their proposed Lighthouse Wind Industrial Wind Turbine Project in Somerset/Yates and the Heritage Wind Industrial Wind Turbine Project in Barre?
Are there additional APEX targets in the Orleans and Niagara counties?…

Source: Wind turbines: Questions that need answers

List of BigWind REJECTIONS all over the USA. Need help? Look here!

Screen Shot 2016-07-21 at 9.19.09 AM

Do you wonder what other states are doing to fight BigWind? It is a growing list of actions that have been taken to protect individuals and communities. Please click the link, below and view the spreadsheet and see if there has been an action that could help you!!!

An interesting addition to our post from 2 days ago…we posted a video of a noisy turbine that is affecting a household in Van Wert, Ohio.  Iberdrola developed this industrial wind site LESS than 6 years ago and we have repeatedly blogged about developers SELLING their sites BEFORE the 10 year mark, due to maintenance issues and the end of the PTC $ at the 10 year mark.  Iberdrola has LEFT THE VAN WERT AREA and sold/merged the project! This household has been UNable to get through the telephone line of the ‘new’ BigWind company that is ‘supposed’ to be operating the site!!! Don’t let this happen to your neighborhood!!!


BREAKING NEWS: Ohio Commissioners reject BigWind PILOT


This is earth shattering!!! Bravo!! Let us pray that this inspires future counties to do the same…

The Logan County Commissioners voted unanimously late Tuesday to reject EverPower’s request for a payment in lieu of taxes to build 18 wind turbines in northern Logan County….

“The Logan County Board of County Commissioners is not convinced that over the life of the project that granting the PILOT would benefit the community. Likewise with respect to job creation, the Logan County Board of County Commissioners is not convinced that the amount of taxes abated would be exceeded by the benefit of gaining relatively few permanent employees,” the resolution reads.

The decision does not prevent EverPower, which filed the request under the name Hardin Wind LLC, from building the turbines in Logan County, but company officials have said they would not likely proceed here without the tax abatement.

The Scioto Ridge Wind Farm includes 87 additional turbines in southern Hardin County that are not affected by the commissioners’ decision and can proceed….

Source: BREAKING NEWS: Commissioners reject wind proposal