Welcome! Please CLICK each TAB at the top for a general info about each subject and then HOVER over each tab to  connect to various links/videos. Don’t forget to follow us via Facebook or Twitter. *New addition! FARM tab. Read about problems that farmers can incur with turbines on their properties!*

Why are we here? Concerned citizens from Ohio want you to Get the Facts about wind energy turbines before it is too late and our neighbors sign long-term leases with foreign companies. These industrial machines may not only impair your quality of life, but may significantly reduce your property value and, later, increase your taxes and electricity rates. We hope to challenge what you believe to be true about this industry by exposing truths.

Our coalition of citizens are not opposed to truly clean energy.  Wind is not the answer. Wind turbines do not reduce our dependence on foreign oil because we only produce a fraction of our energy from oil. Most of it is produced by gas, coal and nuclear. Wind turbines also do not produce anywhere near the amount of energy that they “claim” in the public eye. Statistics from the governmental, EIA, states that ALL wind farms in Ohio for 2012-13 produced LESS than 30% of their capacity; and, even though the wind is free, we know that converting it into electricity is extremely expensive. How many businesses do you know that can survive by producing <30% of what they tell their customers? Even though BigWind only produces 3.5% of the electricity in the USA, they receive 42% of the electrical energy subsidies! Additionally, wind turbines actually increase our dependence on fossil fuels because they must always be backed up, in the fraction of a second, when the winds drop below a certain speed or cease to blow. This causes our fossil fuel plants to constantly “cycle”, something they were not designed to do. Not only are these conditions hard on the power plants, but it increases their emissions; therefore, any negative environmental effects of wind turbines are additive to fossil fuels. And, there are plenty of negative environmental effects. Search our website and you will learn of dirty/toxic Asian Neodymium mining, noise, low frequency infrasound, tons of concrete…and this does not include the tens of thousands of birds, including Eagles, and bats that are slaughtered by the industrial machines.  What effect will massive bat deaths have on our MidWest farmers?

For the first time ever, the America Wind Energy Assoc. hosted an Ohio Wind Energy Summit in September 2013. According to their website, “Ohio was one of the top five fastest growing states for wind capacity additions in 2012, with 313 MW added in 2012 and over 54,000 MW in wind resource potential.” http://www.awea.org/events/event.aspx?eventid=15913  This should concern every citizen in Ohio. With each wind farm taking thousands (10-17,000) of acres, they are planning an explosion across our great state. According to North American Wind Power, the goal is to double the capacity for wind power in Ohio by 2018; that means 300,000 acres will be consumed by wind turbines.

If you still need convincing that our state is at risk, visit the Ohio Power Siting Board website http://www.opsb.ohio.gov/opsb/index.cfm/siting-case-breakdown/preapplication/ and review the preapplication and pending cases. As of April 2014, 10 industrial wind sites have been approved to commence. Once land owners have leased enough land to developers, the company then submits an application to the OPSB. Our legislature gives complete control for approval/rejection to this governing body. You should find it interesting that zero wind applications have been rejected since its inception. Once the OPSB approves a development, the power then shifts to the county commissioners who will probably be asked to accept a PILOT (see $ page), also known as a complete tax abatement. A PILOT allows wind energy developers to give $ back to communities at a fraction of what they should be paying in taxes.

The wind industry wants to spread through Ohio like an algae bloom! Are you aware that Apex (formerly BP Wind Energy North America) has plans to blanket the entire remainder of southern Van Wert county?  They met with Van Wert commissioners 9/12/2014. And that their predecessor wanted to utilize the Spencervill-Elgin railroad to build a transmission line? There are unhappy neighbors in Van Wert county, but most are afraid of the consequences of speaking out because of agreements they have signed or the retribution from others.

Delphos is currently being targeted by Heartland Wind, LLC (of Iberdrola) who has applied to the Ohio Power Siting Board for permission to build the Blue Creek/Dog Creek Windfarms in Van Wert and Paulding counties. Multiple farmers have leased ground in Washington township (bordering Delphos), including near the beautiful golf course. In the spring of 2014, the developer now seeks a PILOT (tax abatement) from the county. . This company is a subsidiary of Iberdrola, one of the world’ leading turbine manufacturers, based in Spain.  Click here to read about the Spanish Green disaster http://www.ncpa.org/sub/dpd/index.php?Article_ID=20628

East of this is the proposed Scioto Ridge wind farm (Hardin/Logan counties) that will include up to 175 turbines that rise 50 towers high. The affected areas include: Hardin and Logan counties, Richland, Rushcreek, McDonald, Lynn and Taylor creek townships, and Roundhead and INDIAN LAKE. Everpower, although headquartered in the USA, is owned by Terra Firma, a private equity firm from Europe.  Everpower has also targeted central Ohio, Champaign county for Buckeye Wind I and II; however, they are tied up in litigation. Note that these wind developments often expand in ‘phases’ after their initial build, so don’t think that you are safe!!  And, finally, to the North is a proposed location in Huron county.

Please utilize the tabs on our website to educate yourself about our concerns. The map below is from the National Renewable Energy Lab. Ohio is not even considered a top 10 state for wind potential.  http://smartplanet.com/blog/smart-takes/top-10-states-for-wind-power-in-the-united-states/4439  Additionally, click here for detailed wind information about Ohio Senate Bill310 April, 2014 Tom Stacy SB 310 testimony 04.08.14

So, if we are not even in the ‘top 20′ for windy states, why are they here?

1. Our legislators passed Senate Bill 221. Ohio law (Revised Code Section 4928.64) requires electric distribution utilities and electric services companies to secure a portion of their electricity supplies from alternative energy resources.  By the year 2025, 25 percent of the electricity sold by each utility or electric services company within Ohio must be generated from alternative energy sources. At least 12.5 percent must be generated from renewable energy resources, including wind, hydro, biomass and at least 0.5 percent solar. In addition, at least one half of the renewable energy used must be generated at facilities located in Ohio. All companies must meet annual renewable and solar energy benchmarks that increase as a percentage of electric supply each year.   In other words, we are now mandating that our electric companies purchase renewable power, whether they want to or not.  Source **Update 6/13/2014 The Ohio Senate Bill 310 was signed by Governor Kasich and will ‘freeze’ these mandates x 2 years while a committee reviews the law.**

June 2013 7th Circuit Court of Appeals (Michigan) decision could change this legislation, however.

The court ruled that a state that requires the in-state generation of a particular type of energy, such as wind, is in violation of the Constitution’s commerce clause. Ohio’s renewable-energy law suffers from the same fatal flaw since it, too, places a quota on in-state generation of wind energy.

The Circuit Court also determined that Midwestern ratepayers must pay if new transmission lines are built to deliver wind from remote, unpopulated areas such as parts of Minnesota. Ohio citizens would see their electricity bills increase to pay for these transmission lines, even if we do not need, want or use any wind power at all, given Ohio’s abundant shale gas and relatively low electricity demand.

Two-thirds of the cost of wind development is paid for by taxpayers. New subsidized power from remote states will be paid for by the ratepayer/taxpayer. How much does it cost YOU? Go to the energy subsidy calculator here 


2. Our legislators also passed a P-I-L-O-T as Senate Bill 232, also known as a Payment in Lieu of Taxes. It is a worldwide favorite among wind developers.  This is a complete tax abatement for wind developers.  It allows county commissioners to approve an annual payment, instead of paying traditional taxes (usually approximately $9000 instead of $45,000/turbine). Developers may only be paying 15% of their tax rate with this option.  If county commissioners threaten to deny a PILOT, developers may threaten to pull their project. http://www.ohioline.osu.edu/cd-fact/pdf/4002.pdf

3. At the federal level is the existence of the Wind Production Tax Credit, also known as the PTC. It has been extended multiple times and has now been in existence for most of the past 30 years. It is essentially a tax, collected from all US taxpayers, that is provided as a subsidy to wind developers. It amounts to $0.022/kWh of electricity produced ($23/MW) for the first 10 years of a project’s life. (This is why many developers “sell” their wind farms before they hit the 10 year mark. Operating and Maintenance costs, coupled with the lack of the PTC, don’t make financial sense.) In actuality, it is worth closer to $0.034/kWh because it is applied after taxes. Look at your electric bill and you will see this is almost a 40% subsidy. A recent 1 year extension of the PTC by Congress is estimated to cost the taxpayer $12Billion.

BUT WAIT, the other power producers enjoy subsidies, so the PTC just levels the playing field, right? NO!

In order to compare the industries, you must look at the subsidies per unit of production and the Institute for Energy Research did that. http://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/2011/08/03/eia-releases-new-subsidy-report-subsidies-for-renewables-increase-186-percent/

According to our Congressional Budget Office (CBO), wind is actually getting subsidies more than 12x that of oil and gas and 6.5x that of nuclear. Is this a level playing field? Additionally, also according to our CBO in March, 2013, almost 75% of energy subsidies for 2013 will go to renewable energy.  Wind has led the renewable sector with a more than 10 fold increase in federal subsidies. Between the production tax credit and other advantages, it is estimated that BigWind is paid $56.29/MW (according to the EIA). Natural gas, oil and coal only receive 6.4cents and nuclear only receives $3.14. http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-perspective/030714-692531-taxpayers-hit-hard-for-wind-subsidies.htm

Although there are more, these are 3 of the biggest reasons that the wind energy developers are in Ohio. It is driven by cash, period. Would you be interested in helping us spread the truth at a local event in your area? If so, please contact us via the form. Thank you!


NREL national wind map

NREL national wind map